What are the Symptoms of Ear Barotrauma?
Barotrauma affecting the middle ear is referred to as ‘Otic Barotrauma’ and is the most common type of Barotrauma. Air at an altitude of 8000 feet is around 30% greater in volume than the same amount of air at sea level. During ascent, the pressure differential across the ear drum causes the middle ear gas to expand, and vice-versa during descent.
Without equalisation of pressure between the middle ear and the cabin air pressure, the ear drums stretches and causes pain.
Otic barotrauma is graded according to its severity – the most mild form is pain without any signs, then earache with a red ear drum, followed by earache with bleeding on the eardrum, and finally perforation of the eardrum when the pain is immediately alleviated. Most perforations heal fine within six weeks.
How may ear Barotrauma be prevented?
The eustachian tube connects the middle ear to the back of the upper respiratory tract (Nasopharynx). The tube has a one-way valve that allows the middle ear to ventilate. During ascent, the air travels the “right way” across the valve – from the middle ear to the nasopharynx. The middle ear automatically ventilates during ascent – no action by passenger or pilot is required.
Descent is a different matter. The air now needs to travel “against” the closed eustachian tube – from the nasopharynx to the middle ear. Action by the pilot is required to facilitate this process. The most common ways to equalise middle ear pressure are:
- Yawn or chew/swallow
- Move the jaw from side to side
- Valsalva: Blow air forcibly against the closed nostrils to force air up the eustachian tube.
At sea level, air pressure is around 760mmHg, and at 8,000 feet the air pressure is 570mmHg (25% less) – a pressure difference of 190mmHg. The valsalva manoeuvre will only work up to a maximum pressure differential of around 110mmHg. So it will take at least two well-spaced Valsalva manoeuvres to equalise the pressure during descent. Don’t leave Valsalva too late or it won’t work.
Barotrauma is most likely during desent. The altitude may reduce by up to 500 fpm without discomfort in most people – theat happens to be the same same rate of ascent or descent expected by ATC during a climb or descent instruction.
Pilots should perform the Valsalva Manoeuvre according to:
- The rate of descent in a non-pressurised aircraft, or
- The rate of reduction in aircraft pressurisation in a pressurised aircraft. Rate of change of cabin altitude during descent is lower than the rate of pressure change during climb – partly to help reduce the risk of Barotrauma that is otherwise more common during descent.
What medical conditions can get in the way of effective mddle ear pressure equalisation?
Equalisation of pressure may be prevented when a pilot:
- is travelling with a cold
- has eustachian tube dysfunction
Someone with a cold will probably not be able to equalise the pressures and is at increased risk of Otic Barotrauma. Pilots learn at an early stage of their flying training not to fly with a cold.
The valsalva manoeuvre will only work up to a maximum pressure differential of around 110mmHg which works out as roughly a change in (cabin) altitude of 4000 feet – don’t leave Valsalva too late or it won’t work.
What are the other types of Barotrauma?
Gas in other body cavities may also be affected:
- Sinuses where the air may not be able to equalise during a cold or Sinusitis. Sinus Barotrauma is most likely to effect the larger sinuses that have a relative narrow opening into the nasopharynx – The Frontal & Maxillary Sinuses. Barotrauma of the frontal sinuses causes a headache above and behind the eyes, whilst barotrauma of the Maxillary sinuses cause pain in the cheeks which may be felt as dental pain.
- Gastrointestinal Tract: Air also expands on ascent which may cause belching, flatulence, or discomfort – even pain.
- Teeth: Small amounts of air may be trapped under fillings or cavities. Expansion of air during ascent will cause severe toothache that may be incapacitating. More commonly, pain felt in the dental area is from the sinuses.